ARIN Advisory Council member, Cathy Aronson, is at IETF 88 in Vancouver, BC, Canada this week. Follow along as she shares hers findings with us on TeamARIN!
Guest blog post by Cathy Aronson
The first day of IETF is in full swing. There is a lot of IPv6 activity today and I will write about that next. First, I feel that I need to emphasize something that happened this afternoon. In my opinion it is of particular interest to the ARIN community.
This afternoon was the Internet Governance BoF. The mailing list is firstname.lastname@example.org (subscribe by sending email to email@example.com). The IETF, like ARIN and the RIRs, is starting to get involved actively in the Internet Governance Forum (IGF) and other Internet governance activities. I think this is a good idea. The thing that got me to the microphone in the session today is the fellow who stood up and said that part of the solution to the problem is to give countries large blocks of IP addresses. Someone stood up at a past IETF and asserted the same thing. The theory is that there is so much address space in IPv6 that it’s basically infinite (which of course it isn’t) and that we should just make every government happy and just give each a huge block.
I went to the microphone to explain that there is a global bottom up process for handing out IP addresses and each region sets that region’s policies. I suggested that the IETF folks become familiar with that and not suggest that blocks be given to governments. I am particularly passionate about this because if the IETF asserts that the RIRs don’t work or that they should be bypassed that is not good for the Internet routing system (at least in my opinion). Even worse in this case it is as if some folks in the IETF have no idea that the RIR system exists.
In addition assigning address blocks geographically, although an interesting intellectual exercise, is not technically feasible. The aggregation is done on Internet Service Provider (ISP) boundaries not on geographic boundaries. Sure, occasionally this mimics the geography but more often it doesn’t match the geography.
In my opinion it’s discouraging that folks at the IETF are asserting that a fix to Internet governance is breaking routing and aggregation. I encourage folks who are interested to join the mailing list and participate in guiding the IETF’s role in Internet governance.